The Michigan Division of the Legal professional Basic introduced on Friday that the U.S. Courtroom of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit would overview arguments on whether or not Legal professional Basic Dana Nessel’s case to close down Enbridge’s Line 5 ought to be heard in federal or state court docket.
Nessel initially sued Enbridge in state court docket in 2019, litigating the case for greater than a yr. The state court docket ordered Enbridge to close down its Line 5 pipelines for a number of weeks in the summertime of 2020 with a view to guarantee their security.
Line 5 runs for 645 miles from Northwest Wisconsin into Michigan’s Higher Peninsula, below the Straits of Mackinac, by the Decrease Peninsula into Sarnia, Canada. It transports about 23 million gallons of crude oil and liquid pure fuel day by day.
Based on the Division of the Legal professional Basic, Nessel and Enbridge each filed motions asking the state court docket to resolve the case. Nevertheless, Enbridge filed a movement to have the case moved to federal court docket, with Federal Decide Janet Neff finally ruling the case can be heard within the U.S. District Courtroom for the Western District of Michigan.
Whereas Neff denied Nessel’s movement to remand the case again to state court docket, Nessel appealed the choice and requested Neff certify the case for interlocutory enchantment which is able to enable the Sixth Circuit Courtroom of Appeals to overview whether or not the case belongs in state or federal court docket earlier than it’s totally litigated in federal court docket. Neff granted Nessel’s request in February.
Now that the case might be heard by the Sixth Circuit Courtroom, each events will file briefs and argue earlier than a panel of judges at a date to be decided. The Sixth Circuit Courtroom will then decide whether or not the case might be despatched again to state court docket, or proceed in federal court docket.
“As Michigan’s prime legislation enforcement official, I introduced this case ahead on behalf of the Individuals of Michigan to guard Michigan’s Nice Lakes,” Nessel stated in an announcement.
“It’s a Michigan case that belongs in a Michigan court docket. … Immediately the Sixth Circuit granted my request to overview this vital matter, and I’m hopeful that they are going to ship this case again to state court docket the place it belongs,” she stated.
Nevertheless, Enbridge stated it expects the matter will stay in federal court docket.
“Immediately’s resolution merely permits the Legal professional Basic to pursue an enchantment of Decide Neff’s resolution from August 2022 that this case correctly belongs in federal court docket. We’re assured that the Sixth Circuit will finally agree with Decide Neff’s resolution,” Enbridge spokesperson Ryan Duffy stated in an e-mail to the Advance.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX